Old Restaurants in Indiana We Wish Would Come Back
Source: Na / na
Old Restaurants in Indiana We Wish Would Come Back
Indiana has long been a food-loving state.
From drive-ins to fine dining, our local restaurant scene has seen unforgettable places come and go.
Whether you grew up in Indianapolis, Bloomington, Fort Wayne, or beyond—chances are you still crave a slice of the past.
Here’s a list of beloved Indiana restaurants that closed their doors but left a lasting legacy.
Some haven’t been gone long, others have been closed for decades, but all hold a special place in Hoosier hearts.
Here are Old Restaurants in Indiana We Wish Would Come Back:
1. Brown Derby – Various Locations
Old-school elegance with steaks, French onion soup, and dim lighting.
2. Ch-Chi's
This national Mexican chain had a big presence in Indiana throughout the ’80s and ’90s. Known for fried ice cream, chimichangas, and endless chips and salsa, it was the go-to spot for birthdays and family celebrations before closing after a major recall in the early 2000s.
3. Sam’s Subway Restaurant Group – Indianapolis
From black bottom pie to kosher deli sandwiches and even a restaurant built to look like a cave, Sam’s was unforgettable until it went bankrupt in 1978.
4. Key West Shrimp House – Indianapolis & More
Steak, seafood, and porthole windows made this southside location feel like a ship at sea.
5. Roselyn Bakery – Statewide
Home to Sweetheart Coffee Cakes and Zebra Brownies, this bakery’s signs and sweets are still found in Kroger stores today.
6. The Tea Room at L.S. Ayres – Indianapolis
This elegant downtown spot served velvet chicken soup, pot pies, and kids’ “hobo lunches.” The recreated version at the Indiana State Museum still draws crowds during the holidays.
7. Paramount Music Palace – Indianapolis
More than dinner—this was a show. Built around a Wurlitzer organ, it served pizza and pasta with a side of Star Wars themes and sing-alongs.
8. Snooty Fox – Nora Neighborhood, Indy
A British-style pub revamped by Restaurant: Impossible in 2011, but sadly closed soon after.
9. Burger Chef – Statewide
Founded in Indy in 1957, Burger Chef revolutionized fast food with its Big Chef burger and the original Funmeal—pre-dating the Happy Meal.
10. The Glass Chimney – Carmel
Fine dining with European flair and a legendary Austrian chef. Opened in 1976, closed after 32 years.
11. Acapulco Joe’s – Indianapolis
One of the first Mexican restaurants in Indy, it was a favorite for tacos and patriotism—playing “God Bless America” every day at noon.
12. Tee Pee Restaurant – Indianapolis
A true icon with its giant teepee roof, this drive-in was a favorite for burgers, pies, and teenage cruising until it closed in the early 1980s.
13. The Huddle – Indianapolis
A 24-hour diner chain known for its massive menus and breakfast anytime. All locations closed by 1976.
14. Shakey’s Pizza Parlor – Indianapolis
With live music, silent movies, and family-style pizza, it was a go-to from the ’60s to ’80s.
15. Don the Beachcomber – South Bend
A tiki bar and restaurant that brought Polynesian flair and mystery cocktails to northern Indiana.
16. Hollywood Bar & Filmworks – Indianapolis
Before luxury dine-in theaters, this downtown gem offered dinner and a movie in one experience.
Old Restaurants in Indiana We Wish Would Come Back was originally published on b1057.com
